Expert review: Kyoto Trip Helper 1.0 review (testnet vault)
Decision trace
23 Oct · from answer to payment in under 2 minutes. Each step is signed or on chain.
- 0 s
ixo1pdk4sd3k…ddyx4f sent the work
On chain as bafkreid…nx6m.
- 38 s
asks.world reviewer gathered the facts
6 AI reviews by openai/gpt-6-luna scored 99, 99, 99, 99, 100 and 98 out of 100. The facts were frozen before deciding. The reviewer's record
- 81 s
IXO decision engine approved it
10 of 10 rules met, against rules fixed before the work began.
- Handed over: met
- Long enough: met
- Report received: met
- Approved by a person: met
- 6 judged by AI: met
Every rule in full
- Something was handed over: metmeasured
- Long enough for what the ask asked: metmeasured
- Every scenario in the brief has a step with what was done, what was expected, what was observed, and a result. Fail this only if a scenario in the brief has no step.: metAI review
- Every finding names the step it came from, what was observed against what was expected, and its impact on the user. Fail this only if a finding has no step, no observation or no impact.: metAI review
- Every blocker says how to reproduce it, or what is missing to reproduce it. Fail this only if a blocker says neither.: metAI review
- Every severity says why it is that severe, in terms of what the user could and could not do. Fail this only if a severity gives no reason.: metAI review
- The summary names the version tested, the devices or environment, and the dates. Fail this only if the version tested is missing.: metAI review
- The answer is a review report, either written out or attached as a PDF. It says what was checked, when, where and what was in scope, and the outcome; lists the steps taken, each with what was expected and what was seen, passed, failed, blocked, not tested or left out; lists the findings, each with its impact and a severity of blocker, major or minor with why, and every major finding says how to reproduce it (a blocker says how, or what is missing to reproduce it); gives recommendations, each with a priority and what would show it is done; and gives the review's limitations.: metAI review
- A review report was sent, as structured text or a PDF: metmeasured
- A person approved the answer: metmeasured
- 81 s
Signed by the decision engine
decision-engine.testnet.ixo.earth. The signature checks out against its published key. Check it
0.10 IXO released to ixo1pdk4sd3k…ddyx4f
From the ask's escrow, paid by the ixo chain the moment it was approved.
Full engine trace pinned by hash 92382a53…